Dear Sir Elton.
So should you perform in Israel? Well you’re going to hear some rather dubious arguments in favor of performing.
Israel is the only gay friendly in the Middle East. So what? It’s a liberal democracy it would be bizarre and shameful if it wasn’t. What next David Cameron slashing child benefit because we don’t practise child sacrifice in the UK?
And implying that because you belong to one persecuted minority you should identify automatically with all those who don’t actively persecute said minority. Is a bit patronising to say the least.
Next up Israel is the only democracy in the Middle East. Well yes, but that’s a double edged sword. Liberal democracies with the rule of law are expected to abide by their own laws and the international bodies they belong to. If Israel is a democracy that continually breaks it’s own laws then it’s a bit pointless. Kind of akin to weeping of Watership Down whilst dynamiting rabbit burrows, or beating one’s spouse with a copy of The Female Eunuch.
But I still think you should play in Israel. Why you may ask?
Israel really is a democracy, with freedom of speech. Israel doesn’t need to be ignored nor should it’s mistake be endorsed.
Play your concerts but criticise, criticise fiercely. A satirical version of Rocketman, Yellow Brick road to failed peace plan, or the Zion Kingdom?
Ask to see the wall, the camps and the checkpoints. If there is one massive diference between Israel and South Africa it’s that Israel really does have freedom of speech. It means it’s citizens truly are responsible for the decisions of it’s governments.
Second reason. The people opposing your tour do seem to have lost some perspective. They concentrate on Israel because a liberal, democracy with freedom of travel is vulnerable. Make their lives bitter enough and their young people will leave or suffer.
This is perverse to the point of madness. Iran where prodemocracy supporters are shot in the street and the rebelious, gay or just free willed face the most horrendous punishments. These countries are left alone, because why bother? Their citizens are to scared or endangered by the state to make a fuss. A vote for liberalism and freedom from opression becomes an endorsment for some of the harshest regimes in the world.
One last point. You will hear no doubt much of the homophobia of the Palestinian government. Well it’s very real, but it’s the sad result of how all opressed people will eventually turn in on themselves. The worst bullys are always those who were bullied themselves. Don’t view this as a reason not to support them. Rather take the view that this may well disapear when the opressed on all sides no longer feel put upon.



