Archive for October, 2009

Review: Brothers

Wednesday, October 14th, 2009

Don Reo is a seasoned TV writer, his work spans from Jimmy Durante Presents the Lennon Sisters (1969), through M*A*S*H (1976), Blossom (1990), Everybody Hates Chris (2007) and now in 2009 he gives us Brothers.  On paper this could be a worthwhile sitcom, we have Daryl Mitchell, former American footballer Michael Strahan, Carl ‘Apollo Creed’ Weathers and the fabulous CCH Pounder. In reality we have an overwhelmingly weak and predictable sitcom that will be lucky last far past the two episodes that have already aired.

In the pilot we meet two brothers Mike (Michael Strahan) an American Football Player and Chill (Daryl Mitchell) who is paralysed from the waste down after a car accident.  They brought back together by their strong willed mother (CCH Pounder) with news that their father (Carl Weathers) had suffered a stroke. In reality there are many secrets under the surface, Chill’s restaurant is failing, Mike has been screwed out of all his money by his agent and while their father has not suffered a stroke, he does seem to have Alzheimer. We learn that brothers have fallen out because Chill blames Mike for the accident since he was supposed to pick him up from a party and after he no showed he got a ride with a friend who was drunk. Their mother needs them all to pull together so they can survive these difficulties.

There could be a good blend real life difficulties to bring out humour, instead we are left catchphrases “He’s an idiot and I love him”, an over used joke about shaven testicles or “wiggly-do”as it is called and gags about the gap in Strahan’s teeth. When all is said and done, you have to look at CCH Pounder and wonder what the hell she is wasting her time doing this crap for. This is not to say she is bad, she is the best thing in the show and it is great seeing her do comedy, but coming off The Shield , you would think she could spot a good script, but their precious little for her to work with here.

The second episode appeared to erase all talk of the father’s Alzheimers as well as much of the resentment between the brothers.  Money troubles seems to have eased since they all joined forces to work in the restaurant and everyone enjoys a lifestyle that would make the average American’s jaw drop – they have a pool house and claim money is tight.

Had not The Beautiful Life: TBL already been cancelled I would have put this top of my list of shows that would disappear and never be spoke of again, as it is we will have to wait to see how long it will last.

Written by: Don Reo
Directed by: Ted Wass
Starring: Michael Strahan, Daryl “Chill” Mitchell, Carl Weathers, CCH Pounder
Date premièred: 25th September 2009
UK Details: TBC – but very unlikley

Review: Mercy

Wednesday, October 7th, 2009

As I have said before, 2009 sees no less that 8 new medical dramas each looking to find its niche. Mercy decided to view the hospital from the point of view of the unsung heroes known as the nurses, this of course might have been an original idea had not Showtime already produced Nurse Jackie and TNT produced Hawthrone.  With the loss of ER this is an important show for NBC and although planned to air mid season it was rushed out to fill the gap caused by a delay in the production of Parenthood.

Don’t under estimate the nurses, on her way to work Veronica (Taylor Schilling) attends the victim of a car crash after the saving some guys life, she threatened with law suit after his fiancé discovers she is only a nurse and therefore knows nothing. In actual fact Veronica the sexy nurse is an Iraq vet who has seen it all, we don’t know how she ended up back in a New Jersey hospital, but I am sure there is a good reason. New girl Chloe (Michelle Trachtenberg) arrives for her first day and despite being top of her class the slightest whiff of reality freezes her in her tracks. There is the usual office politics and power games between the doctors as Veronica up stages them with her in depth knowledge.  Of course her private life doesn’t run smoothly either, separated from her husband she sneaks off for rendezvous with one of the Doctors and at the end of a busy day the girls all head down to the local bar.

Comparisons to Nurse Jackie are immediately obvious; our lead character is a nurse, with a wealth of experience that surpasses the doctors. She rebels against authority for the good of the patient and carries out an affair with one of the doctors. Fair enough, it is understandable why a show would pick such a professionally moral character, with slight amoral private life.  Then we turn to the other nurses, we have the new girl Chloe who has a love for colourful scrubs, we switch to nurse Jackie where we have the new girl Zoey… who has a love for colourful scrubs. Then we have the shaven headed ethnic gay nurse, sure, Mercy has the Hispanic Angel, while Nurse Jackie has the middle eastern Mo-mo. This is not to say that Mercy has stolen these ideas and characters, it is just one of those horrible coincidences that must have made series creator Liz Heldens’ head burst. On the plus side not everyone has Showtime, so for majority of the audience these characters will feel at least somewhat fresh and original.

In conclusion this is just another medical drama that fails to throw anything new into the mix.  Nurse Jackie felt more real even though the situations were more exaggerated.  When you look at 46 year Edie Falco you think there is someone who has seen it all, but young newcomer Taylor Schilling would more easily pass as an intern than an experienced nurse. The nurses work hard and they play hard, if you like medical drama, this will probably float your boat, if you want more out of hour of TV you probably aren’t watching this anyway.

Created and Written by: Liz Heldens
Directed by: Adam Bernstein
Starring: Taylor Schilling, Jaime Lee Kirchner, Michelle Trachtenberg, James Tupper, Diego Klattenhoff, James LeGros, Delroy Lindo, Kate Mulgrew, Guillermo Díaz
Date premièred: 23rd September 2009
UK Details: TBC

Review: Cougar Town

Sunday, October 4th, 2009

Sitting down to watch the much hyped Cougar Town I was surprised by its 22 minute run time, I had been expecting something more akin to Desperate Housewives, but since Eastwick seems to have gone that route, the single camera sitcom format is perfect. Created by Bill Lawrence the man behind Spin City and Scrubs, it stars Courtney Cox (Friends and Dirt) the show is certainly packing some veteran talent, even relative new comer Dan Byrd (Aliens in America) delivers a confident performance.

Newly divorced realtor Jules (Courtney Cox) is suddenly aware of her age, her sagging  body and prospect that she is doomed to spend the rest of her life a single mum. Although she thinks she has a close and kooky relationship with her son Travis (Dan Byrd), she is unaware of how she embarrasses him. Her younger friend Laurie (Busy Phillips) wants to get her out of the house and so she ends up in bar and later back her place to enjoy the benefits of sex with younger guy. A new world has opened up and for the first time in a long time she feels alive and unfortunately for her 17 year old son this is something he is going to have to get use to.

This is one busy pilot, almost as if it was written for an hour slot and boiled down, scenes struggle to last longer than the annoying guitar music that segways over each cut. At such break neck speed it is hard to keep track with all the characters, and rather than well formed B and C stories we get one big over complicated A story. What makes this frustrating is there is a lot of really good moments, characters and ideas here, we just are not given the time to enjoy them.  Hopefully as the series continues the pace will slow down so we catch our breath and enjoy the show.

We have become very use to seeing older guys with younger girls, but the Cougar movement is certainly challenging those expectations.  We have seen it in Desperate Housewives, joked about it on SNL, sighed at Accidentally on Purpose, but Cougar Town despite its title, might be the first to really examine the plight of the single middle aged woman.  The term Cougar is almost a misnomer here, Jules is just woman who has opened her eyes to the possibilities before her, she might even have the power to re-brand the Cougar as something exciting rather than scary. However, there is one bug, Courtney Cox still looks kinda hot, she still has a great body and all those other shallow things we look for, the idea that she is over the hill just is not realistic so it is hard to make an emotional connection to her dilemma when many women that age (and younger) would kill to look that good.

This is a fairly solid first outing for Bill Lawrence’s new show, scrubs had run its course (however, it is being rebooted later this year as Scrubs: Interns), so it must be good to for him to sink his teeth into something new.  The characters are all interesting to watch, although Courtney Cox’s new character doesn’t feel like she has too many differences to her most famous role as Monica, while Christa Miller is playing nearly exactly the same character as she did on scrubs. This isn’t bad thing, the actors are very comfortable in these shoes and revel in the performance. The comedy is more mature than we have seen from Bill in the past due to the sexual nature of the story.  This doesn’t feel like Scrubs or Spin City dumped in Florida, it stands confident in its own shoes.

The first episode performed very well and I expect in the coming weeks the initial order of 13 episodes to extended for a full 22.

Created and Written by: Bill Lawrence, Kevin Biegel
Directed by: Bill Lawrence
Starring: Courteney Cox, Dan Byrd, Ian Gomez, Brian Van Holt, Josh Hopkins, Christa Miller, Busy Philipps
Date premièred: 23rd September 2009
UK Details: Living 2010


Pilot Watch is proudly powered by WordPress, Install WordPress. web hosting
Entries (RSS) and Comments (RSS).

Privacy Policy