Archive for March, 2010

Review: Parenthood (2010)

Sunday, March 14th, 2010

Once upon a time Steve Martin was an A-list star and little Richie Cunningham was yet to win an Oscar, they teamed with Neo and a bunch of other faces you recognise from the 80s to make Parenthood.  Such a success was this multi generational look at one of life’s greatest challenges network TV rushed out to make a small screen version. Ed Begley Jr, David Arquette and Leonardo DiCaprio took on the roles of their big screen counterparts, unfortunately for Leo, the series followed the fate of other 80s and early 90s movies turned TV shows (Working Girl, Ferris Bueller, Uncle Buck and Baby Talk (based on the film Look Who’s Talking)) and lasted only on series.

Jump forward 20 years and the Buckmans are now the Bravermans and the new head of the house is Six Feet Under star Peter Krause. Originally intended for a September airing it pushed back to the mid-season as actress Maura Tierney was diagnosed with breast cancer, as a result Mercy was brought up in its place. Tiernay went on to leave the series due to her treatment and Lauren Graham took her place.

Parenthood is not so much a spin of off the film, but a re-imagining, both the show and film start off at the same point and at least for the pilot follow a very similar path. The premise is to show 4 siblings as they struggle at various stages of parenthood (the parents of teenagers, toddlers, tweens and the expecting all watched over by the veteran of child rearing), the scope is huge, so how does the show stack up? Well its a bit of mixed bag, the plot follows the film closely minus the huge baby closing. However, by crushing a 2 hour film down 40 minutes you end up with quite an unfocused story with way too many events that conveniently happen over the space of a week.    Adam Braverman (Krause) and the problems with his nervous son which is so prominent in the film is quickly pushed into the background as we instead follow newly divorced mother of two, Sarah (Lauren Graham) as she relocates closer to her family and starts dating again. All the time the patriarch of the family pushes everyone to stand up to conflict while his second son suddenly finds himself engaged to stop his girlfriend impregnating herself with a turkey baster only to find out he fathered another son some years before with a different woman. The final couple have to deal with the effects of the a working mum and child who prefers her dad to do things for her.

So basically there is a shit load going that is only made easy to follow if you have seen the film and know what to expect. They would have been better served to drop some of these subpolts from the pilot and extending them into the series as a whole. Often pilots try to take what will happen in the first series and crush down into the first episode to give people a taste of what they are going to see, but with so many subplots and characters you can struggle to figure out whose story you are suppose to be following.  Overall you have great actors and interesting dynamics, but there was nothing here in the plot or characters to get me excited to see the rest of the series. With other new shows like The Middle and Modern Family covering similar ground this season, Parenthood stands out as being a comic drama rather than a sitcom, although its execution is not as good as the more acclaimed Modern Family.

The series premiere of Parenthood was dedicated to the memory of Nora O’Brien, a Vice President at NBC, who died on the set of Parenthood in April 2009 in Berkeley, California.

Written by: Jason Katims
Directed by: Thomas Schlamme
Starring: Peter Krause, Lauren Graham, Dax Shepard, Monica Potter, Erika Christensen, Sam Jaeger
Date premièred: 2nd March2010
UK Details: TBC

<object width=”560″ height=”340″><param name=”movie” value=”http://www.youtube.com/v/5vCDj0tsEp0&hl=en_GB&fs=1&”></param><param name=”allowFullScreen” value=”true”></param><param name=”allowscriptaccess” value=”always”></param><embed src=”http://www.youtube.com/v/5vCDj0tsEp0&hl=en_GB&fs=1&” type=”application/x-shockwave-flash” allowscriptaccess=”always” allowfullscreen=”true” width=”560″ height=”340″></embed></object>

Review: Spartacus: Blood and Sand

Friday, March 5th, 2010

Starz is a premium priced channel in America prominently showing first run movies, in recent years the channel has moved towards the successful model of HBO and Showtime by producing their own first run TV series. A TV series spin off of Crash and Party Down have enjoyed a moderate amount of success, but their latest addition is Spartacus: Blood And Sand.

The first I hard of this series was an article about how male members of the cast were offered prosthetic penises nicknamed “Kirk Douglas” after the star of the classic Kubrick movie to cover manhood or lack there of. Starz looking to make a name for it’s original drama has created a series that  promised much violence and plenty of full frontal nudity from both sexes.

In the pilot we meet a unnamed Thracian who is drafted into the Roman army in order fight of a barbarian hoard and protect his village. When the Roman commanders change tact leaving his village open to attack he leads a mutiny and manages to save his wife even as his village burns.  Husband and wife share one night together before Roman soldiers abduct them both, she is sold in slavery, he made to fight in the gladiatorial arena.  Here the Thracian defies all expectations and takes down 4 Gladiators, winning the crowd and saving his life.  He is then sold into a Gladiator school as a valuable commodity and given the name Spartacus.

Originally I suspected this would be a mini series expending on the story presented in the 1960 film, however it appears not only does this series run for 13 episodes, but a second series has also recently been picked up. The series is said to focus on Spartacus’ early years, but really just means his life as a Gladiator, it is unclear whether the first season will see the start of his slave rebellion against Rome.

My first reaction to this series was that it looked like a poor rip off of 300, a 225 if you will, but this is only one piece of the puzzle – the slow motion fights. For dialogue they have thrown in the original Spartacus, while HBO’s Rome provides influence for the explicit sex.  Finally Gladiator provides a great deal of influence for the series’ title character; Spartacus was a slave turned Gladiator turned leader of an army, here we have husband warrior sold into a Gladiator school. The Spartacus in this series has no bonds with slavery, there is no hint of what the man shall become which seems very short sighted. Away from the sex and violence the series feels like a movie of the week with melodramatic emotions and swearing thrown in just because they can.

Beyond the attempts at pushing the limits there is an interesting story here, Spartacus is a man driven by desire to be reunited with his wife and it is a bold move by the writers to remove the love interest so quickly and leave him without for so long. The series proves to be a bit of a guilty pleasure, a testosterone fuelled soap opera that will probably not draw new subscribers to Starz premium channel, but at least give them some headlines for future series they choose to produce.

Written by: Steven S. DeKnight
Directed by: Rick Jacobson
Starring: Andy Whitfield, Erin Cummings, John Hannah, Lucy Lawless, Peter Mensah, Manu Bennett
Date premièred: 22nd January 2010
UK Details: Summer 2010

Review: Past Life

Tuesday, March 2nd, 2010

Show creator David Hudgins has enjoyed some great success of late taking a supervising producer credit on the critically acclaimed drama series Friday Night Lights, so it is no surprise that he got the chance to create his own show. Past Life is loosely based on The Reincarnationist, a crime thriller by M.J. Rose, it is about a man who solves modern crime through channelling his past life in ancient Rome. The TV show takes the twist that other people experiencing past life intruding on their present happens because their past selves want to right a wrong.

In the pilot we are thrown right in when high school kid keeps getting hallucinations, having sought help everywhere else his parents turn to Dr. Kate McGinn who offers the explanation of a past life. Her operation has recently expanded by hiring a cop with past onto the team, Price Whatley gives the formally all Doctor group much needed detective skills (a bit like a reverse Mentalist). Following clues they quickly conclude that the boy has the past life of a murdered girl in him and the reason for her showing herself is to help free her sister who was abducted at the same time, but not murdered. In the end they find the girl who has grown up thinking she was adopted. With the sister reunited the high school boy can get back to living – this makes it feel less like a Past Life and more like a possession, either way, why did the sister wait 15 yeas to show herself. We leave with sceptic cop with a past now a believer and he reveals that he took the job in hope he can contact his dead wife.

The problem with the story in the pilot is that we are dealing with a tragedy around characters that we don’t know and don’t care about. Even the boy who is having flashbacks to his past is hardly featured other than wheeling him out in front of people and locations in order to see if he will go crazy. Our main gang of investigators appear to operate outside of law enforcement but with their full support and trust. This is a gimmick led show that struggles to work convincingly for an episode let alone a series.

Past Life represents the kind of TV shows that drive me nuts. It takes a bullshit science and presents it as reality. In fact if there was anything in this world that even came close to proof of Past Lives it would blow everything we know about the human mind and science out the window. Sure you can say this is fiction, but it is the way that the subject matter is handled. This is presented as the real world in which we live in and if your child is going nuts then forget therapy, just stick him in a chair and let him regress. Other shows like this include Ghost Whisperer and Medium, mainly because it gives credibility to some of the most evil people on the planet. Those who seek to exploit people in their most desperate hour, real police time is wasted and these charlatans are only too happy to profit off the back of someone else’s tragedy. For an insight into what these folk get up to check out Stop Sylvia Browne. Rant over.

While Ghost Whisperer and Medium are enjoying great success, Past Life has not fared so well. After a strong opening the second episode lost 50% of the viewers with episode three continuing the downward slide. The series has been cut short with the remaining four episodes to be dumped in the schedules as some point down the line.

Created / Written by: David Hudgins
Directed by: Deran Sarafian
Starring: Kelli Giddish, Nicholas Bishop, Richard Schiff, Ravi Patel
Date premièred: 9th February 2010
UK Details: TBC


Pilot Watch is proudly powered by WordPress, Install WordPress. web hosting
Entries (RSS) and Comments (RSS).

Privacy Policy