Archive for the ‘Drama’ Category

Review: Boardwalk Empire

Wednesday, September 22nd, 2010

When the city runs dry, the streets will run with blood.

When it comes to ambitious drama series, no other channel can do it as well as HBO. Band Of Brothers, Carnivale and Deadwood are prime examples of stellar production values, quality scripts and great acting with each episode feeling like a fully fledged mini film. With the exception of True Blood, HBO has struggled to find another great drama that would pull in viewers the way The Sopranos and Sex And The City did. Enter Boardwalk Empire written by Sopranos alumni Terrence Winter, staring Steve Buscemi and produced and directed by Martin Scorsese; this is without doubt one of HBOs most ambitious projects to date.

Set in Atlantic City on the eve of prohibition we are introduced to the main character Enoch “Nucky” Thompson (Buscemi) a smooth talking politician making a profitable career as a bootlegger on the side. With the police on side Nucky becomes a powerful contact for Chicago mobsters who are looking get booze to their city and of course he makes a good profit out of the deal. We see a softer side to Nucky when he helps out a pregnant woman married to drunken violent gambler. Meanwhile Jimmy (Michael Pitt)  a World War I vet with the horrors of war still fresh in his mind, returns to Atlantic city  to find everyone else has climbed the ladder of success and he has been left behind, frustrated he teams up with a young Al Capone to make a name for himself.

This is an impressive show in a league of it’s own, with a $20 million budget the production values make it feel more like a movie than a TV series, the attention to detail in the buildings, costume and language create a vivid picture of a fascinating time in American history. Director Martin Scorsese has certainly put his mark on this film with clear echos to his other gangster flick Goodfellas (Freeze Frames on characters, longing sweeping shots, a comic delivering jokes over a pivotal turning point in the story are just a few examples).  It is a bold design that other directors will have to emulate in future episodes, although schedules permitting Scorsese has stated he would like to direct more episodes. I heard some concern before the pilot aired that the show like Mad Men would be rich in texture but weak on story, this is certainly not the case.   This is great writing where character choices drive the story rather than characters reacting to events out of their control, this is what makes a compelling show. The pilot episode, running over 70 minutes, sets up many of the arcs we will be following over the series and the choices made the characters feel like they will have far reaching consequences.

The question is, in Enoch “Nucky” Thompson do we have our new Tony Soprano sized anti-hero? The Sopranos set a very high bar for all shows, not just those appearing on HBO and comparisons are bound to be made, however what made Sopranos such a perfect show is what is missing here. Tony Soprano was at heart a family man, he may break the law and have affairs, but ultimately his children and his mother ruled his actions, his discontent with how the American dream had played out for him was something that everyone could identify with. Boardwalk Empire is an incredible achievement with a great cast of characters (make no mistake Steve Buscemi cuts an imposing presence), but currently it lacks an emotional core that I can identify with. Nucky’s relationship with a pregnant Irish immigrant seems placed to provide that core, but it felt so separate from the central plot that it failed to resonate with me.

Overwhelming positive reaction to series has already led to talk of massive Emmy wins and a mere two days after the premier a second series was ordered.  This is a show that is going to be around and I am sure you will be hearing much more about it.

Written by: Terrence Winter
Based on the Book by: Nelson Johnson
Directed by: Martin Scorsese
Starring: Steve Buscemi, Michael Pitt, Kelly Macdonald, Michael Shannon, Shea Whigham, Aleksa Palladino, Michael Stuhlbarg, Stephen Graham
Date premièred: 19th September 2010
UK Details: TBA

Review: Outlaw

Sunday, September 19th, 2010

Judge, Jury and Defender.

Disclaimer upfront, I have never got into courtroom dramas, maybe because paperwork and research is dull TV so if it is included it is over the top, but this is often substituted for emboldened and passionate oral arguments in the courtroom. For me I like to see the courtroom reserved for special occasions, not a weekly event and I am sure the vast a majority of trials are pretty open and shut cases which only seem fresh to jurors.  Last year The Good Wife received positive attention, proving that Law and Order is not the only legal drama people were willing to invest in.

Outlaw sees Cyrus Garza (Jimmy Smitts) as a right wing supreme court justice who enjoys a drink and a flutter, he is portrayed as both a right wing zealot and the swing vote on the supreme court. It is left up to him to decided whether a man on death row for killing a police officer deserves his case to be heard by the supreme court. Being placed there by the right he is pushed in the direction of not hearing the case, but the death of his father who was an advocate for the little man gives Garza a crisis of conscience and he allows the case to be heard before quitting the court to help defend the man. Garza brings along his clerks who are the usual mix of over the top conflicting personalities we get in these types of dramas (see House, NCIS and The Mentalist), they pretty much take on the task of finding evidence to clear the man’s name before Garza presents his case to the supreme court, the case is not only one but the real killer identified and arrested based on the testimony of one surprise witness. A dark shadow of his gambling debts hang over him as he looks towards a future of fighting cases for the little man.

First of all we have ludicrous premise of a supreme court justice quitting to become a defence lawyer, he goes from the most right wing judge on the court to the an ultra lefty wanting to fight for gay rights and cop killers.  this sudden change of heart comes from him watching a video of his liberal dad. But it gets crazier, he then joins a law firm, names his salary, gets to pick his team and his cases and ends up fights for the man he has granted a retrial to.  This show feels like it was created by a madlib.

Garza is a insert job with a insert vice, he quits to become a insert new job. This really is level of thought that has gone into this premise.  The annoying thing is Jimmy Smitts is a great actor, he has done some fantastic work, his presence alone raises this show up 5 notches to give it 5 notches.  One of the big problems is that Garza takes a huge personal leap at the top of the show, so we don’t care about anything else, we don’t care about the man he is defending, we don’t care about his eclectic yet loyal team and we don’t care about Garza for he has seen the light. The hint of his gambling debts just feels tacked on to add story, but since he has just quit a $250,000 per year job to be a lawyer with the super a high salary I’m guessing he isn’t going have to too many issues paying that money back. There are just no surprises in this show, you know he is going to save this man from death row from the outset, therefore there is no drama.

After the first episode NBC have shifted it to Friday’s in their schedule, it probably won’t be long before it vanishes altogether.

Created / Written by: John Eisendrath
Directed by: Terry George
Starring: Jimmy Smits, David Ramsey, Ellen Woglom, Carly Pope, Jesse Bradford
Date premièred: 15th September 2010
UK Details: TBA

Review: Terriers

Friday, September 17th, 2010

Private Investigators, Dognapping and Murder.

FX is a channel that sits between mainstream channels like ABC, FOX and NBC and subscription channels like HBO and Showtime.  This has led to drama like The Shield, Sons of Anarchy and It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia which are more risqué than shows on the mainstream channels, but avoid on screen graphic violence, sex and language that are common on the subscription channels. The Shield for example is known as one of the most gritty cop dramas ever produced, it deals with drugs, gangs and bad cops and yet not once in the 7 series was the word “Fuck” ever uttered, compare  that Oz, The Wire or Dexter. So when a new FX series starts you know that they will find a way to push the limits, but more importantly, because money is tight, they can not afford to make a series and then cut it from the schedules only show 2 episodes because it wasn’t performing, for this reason the scripts have to be better.

Terriers is a joint venture between Shawn Ryan (Creator of The Shield) and Ted Griffin (Writer of Ocean’s Eleven) and was commissioned for a full series order on the back of this pilot. A full series on FX is around 13 episodes and so shows do not suffer from a sudden order for 9 episodes after the show becomes a hit leaving the writers looking for a way to drag out the series.

In the first episode we see two friends who have a floundering unlicensed private investigator buisness, their services rather than earning them money are more likely to be traded in favours. Hank Dolworth is an ex cop and takes a job from a friend to find his daughter, this leads him and his partner Britt Pollack to a property developer who double hires the PIs to find the girl and return a ‘personal item’ she stole from him. As you would expect things soon spiral out of control and go beyond what the duo can deal with alone. They are left in a situation where they either cut their losses or step up to the big leagues.

I have radically simplified the plot, partly because it was so dense, but also to leave you a few surprises, as this is a show you should check out.  While the Private Investigator backdrop is nothing new (think Raymond Chandler’s Sam Spade or more recent examples such as the brilliant Brick and Jeff Goldblum’s Raines), the character portraits and story structure in this episode of Terriers is superb. From the outset we understand the dynamic between the two friends, we understand an obvious outer struggle (money) and gradually learn the greater personal struggles they need to overcome.  Hank needs to reconcile his past as an alcoholic cop and face up to losing his wife, Britt needs grow up and take more responsibility in the relationship with his girlfriend. Both men are floundering at the start of the episode, but their path is set at the end; as they look forward, the road may be tougher, but the rewards will be greater.

This is a solid first outing, there are some surprises, it is well written but ultimately we are left with all the staples of the genre, the all purpose rich bad guy, friction with the police, casual beatings, sexy vixens. As an example of the genre it is top notch, but adheres a little too close to the formula for it to feel like truly original drama.  I am looking forward to the next episode, but this not quite the must see show I was hoping for.

Created / Written by: Ted Griffin
Directed by: Craig Brewer
Starring: Donal Logue, Michael Raymond-James, Laura Allen, Rockmond Dunbar, Jamie Denbo, Kimberly Quinn
Date premièred: 8th September 2010
UK Details: TBA

Review: Lost Girl

Thursday, September 16th, 2010

Vampires are out, Fairies are in.

Everywhere you look there are zombies, vampires, werewolves and witches thrown in for good measure, superheroes are over saturated leaving writers in a tizzy as to what characteristic they can throw at their character to separate it from the masses. So Michelle Lovretta has turned to fairies for this Canadian supernatural drama.

The story opens with Bo working as a bartender, but she saves a girl from a letchy man using a date rape drug she has to quit her job and leave town, mainly because she seduced and then sucked the life out of him. Being able to suck the life out of bad guys looks like a pretty cool X-Man type power, but like Rouge she can not control this power and be it friend or foe they always end up dead. This most recent kill brings fresh attention to Bo from others just like her.  After tracking her down she discovers that she is a fairy, well a Fae (because that sounds slightly cooler).  Now she knows what she is, she must survive a test and then choose a side. Given a boost from another fairy she succeeds in the challenge and faced with the choice of being in the dark clan or the light clan she picks humans. This will apparently throw off the the carefully crafted balance that has been in existence for years.

In the pilot episode we are thrown a lot of exposition, none which makes much sense, the main character Bo really doesn’t make any choices until the end where she unsurprisingly chooses to join the humans as her side.  This  choice is predictable, but makes little sense since these people knows what she is and have offered to help her manage her abilities so she does not kill everyone she gets close to. Sure making you fight demons for no reason can lead to distrust, but giving you an energy boost before you fight them is nice. Besides it is not like humans have done her any favours, the one girl that likes is the same one who got her noticed in the first place.

The rule book on fairies are not so written as vampires, but so far they look pretty much the same, like vampires they are seductive and feed on the living, only fairies switch blood for life force and take it through a literal kiss rather than the dark kiss. They posses superior strength and live among us with their own rules and with the two sides, it is not so different from the X-Men. Basically you can dress it all up and call it a new idea, but is still derivative of everything else out there.

Created / Written by: Michelle Lovretta
Directed by: John Fawcett
Starring: Anna Silk, Kristen Holden-Reid, Ksenia Solo, Rick Howland
Date premièred: 12th September 2010
UK Details: TBA

Review: Nikita

Tuesday, September 14th, 2010

Tough Chicks With Guns and Explosive Lipstick.

For the big studios no idea is as good as an old idea. Luc Besson’s film Nikita (known as La Femme Nikita in the states) was remade in English as the Point of No Return (also known as The Assassin), this was then re-imagined in the late 90s as TV series La Femme Nikita and now it is pushed out again as part of the 2010 fall schedule. With no kick ass girls on TV right now, this might have seemed like a quick fix to fill the gap, a tried and tested formula with a fresh spin.

The new series opens as the films and TV series have before with a failed pharmacy robbery and dead a cop. Like the original series the girl who gets caught is innocent of murder (in the films she is not).  Before the girl can be tried for her crime, her death is faked and she is recruited into a spy school known as The Division. So this roughly follows the original story, except this girl is not Nikita. We learn Nikita has escaped the Division and now like Quentin Tarantino’s Bride, she wants revenge and will stop at nothing to bring The Division down and rescue the girls and boys who have been sucked into becoming highly skilled assassins against their will. So in a way, this is more a continuation of the series rather than a straight re-imagining.

This is a great example with what is wrong with scripted drama these days.  The production values are sky high, the action scenes are slick and the show is beautiful to look at. This however, is all cosmetic, when it comes to the script, it is thread bare, there is no depth, no challenge, no character development and no real surprises. Nikita as the main character is never legitimately challenged, she sets up all the situations to her advantage and even in the one instant where things seem like they don’t go 100% to plan she pulls out gadget that allows her to escape effortlessly and unhurt. The story is event led from beginning to end, characters don’t have to make tough decisions (even if they look like they are making choice on screen, future revelations show the choice was made long before). In essence all the real story has taken place off screen before we  join the characters on this story, the sacrifices have been made and now it is straight revenge with nothing at stake. Much has been made of the twist on the story, but this actually negates more drama than it creates.

The spy school has changed from being a good organisation that has to enter grey areas for the greater good  and has become a purely evil organisation working for high paying corporations. There is still some grey that made the original story stand out and this comes in the form of Nikita’s desire for revenge and who she is prepared to use to get it.

There are interesting ideas here, but hidden in a plot that fails show any character vulnerability. As a show that wants to promote strong female characters they only suit the male gamers ideal of super slim, sexy, ass kicking assassins who are more likely to use brute force and flexibility than brains.

Original Characters and Story Created by:Luc Besson
Developed and Written by: Craig Silverstein
Directed by: Danny Cannon
Starring: Maggie Q, Lyndsy Fonseca, Shane West, Melinda Clarke, Xander Berkeley
Date premièred: 9th September 2010
UK Details: 7th October, Living

Review: Hellcats

Sunday, September 12th, 2010

That’s Some Peppy Goth.

2009 saw Glee burst onto the scene with mix of tongue in cheek humour, big musical numbers and a cast of entertaining and memorable characters; it was without a doubt the breakout hit of the year and in 2010 Hellcats looks at another aspect of American school life that is alien to us in the UK, the cheerleaders. There are some things about this show that peaked my interest, the series was created by Kevin Murphy who has been head  writer on Desperate Housewives as well as penning musical spoof Reefer Madness . So was this show going to be this year’s Glee or this year’s The Beautiful Life.

The story opens with rock chick Marti who loses her college scholarship and has to find a way to cover the costs of her law degree. When she first sees the cheerleaders, she mocks, but holds some reverence for the athleticism involved especially when one of the lead flyers takes a hard fall.  Luckily for Marti, cheerleaders get a full scholarship and with the flyer down there is a new opening.  Having already got into an argument with the head cheerleader her chances at the auditions look slim until she throws out the set choreography and does her own rock thing that not only impresses the coach but the head cheerleader as well. Everyone is happy except for the girl she replaces who disses her by calling her a “tumbler” before inviting her alcoholic mum along to an important cheerleading qualifying contest.

Hellcats is based on the book Cheer!: Inside the Secret World of College Cheerleaders by journalist Kate Torgovnick; Glee for cheerleading it is not (although the CW does site the big dance numbers as reason for picking up the show) and if you have seen Bring It On this really doesn’t add anything fresh. The show itself even references the quint essential cheerleading movie when Marti prepares for her audition by watching the DVD. Personally both in story and style the show reminded me of The Beautiful Life, a girl from the outside enters a competitive new world and has to move in with a bunch of ambitious back stabbing beauties and try retain her sense of identity.

The characters are tired stereotypes we have seen over and over again;  nothing in the story is surprising, from the auditions to the importance of the team cheerleading to victory.  Villains are villains for the sake of the story with no real reason behind why they act the way do, while the romances which are yet to blossom are painfully obvious. The script is tired and the acting at points painful to watch. Devoid of surprises it is left up to the glitter to entertain, this comes in the form of sexy cheerleaders  (both male and female) and impressive and well choreographed dance numbers.

For some reason Smallville’s Tom Welling is very much involved in this project, he apparently feels that cheerleading has not been fully exploited on TV.  He maybe right here. We have come to learn from almost every other teen series that cheerleaders are all bitchy sluts, but with the story focused on them and a source material that throws up the real drama behind the scenes, this could be an interesting series. However the audience is not the same as Friday Night Lights and so that rich source material stands a good chance of getting sidelined for the usual relationship drama and backstabbing storylines.

This show is out the gate early, (the real onslaught of pilots doesn’t happen for two weeks) and this grace period may allow it to pick up and hold an audience that will keep it from cancellation, right now I don’t think it will get a full season order and will probably wrap up after its first 13 episodes.

Created / Written by: Kevin Murphy
Directed by: Allan Arkush
Starring: Alyson Michalka, Gail O’Grady, Ashley Tisdale, Heather Hemmens, Robbie Jones, Matt Barr
Date premièred: 8th September 2010
UK Details: TBA

Review: The Big C

Saturday, September 11th, 2010

What’s Worse than a Maggot in Your Apple? Cancer.

Showtime’s new comic drama was originally called The C Word, but I guess they worried that Americans might think it was some kind of prequel or spin off to The L Word. The Big C sees yet another female led show on the channel’s schedules (Nurse Jackie, United States of Tara and Weeds still running and The L Word, Secret Diary Of A Call Girl and Fat Actress doing reruns), this is something that others appear to shy away from, certainly other powerhouses like HBO, FX and AMC, for all their great drama have not a single female led show among them… well maybe at push True Blood.

In the pilot we join Cathy after she has been diagnosed with melanoma, her life dramatically changed she embarks upon on a journey to reclaim her life.  She turns around and examines what her life has become, for too long has she taken for granted, ignored and made to feel her ideas are wrong or unimportant.  The cancer gives her the wake up call to take the opportunities to do and say all the things she wanted to.  All the relationships in her life change, her man child husband, her mollycoddled son, her eco crazy brother, her grumpy neighbour and her overweight student all get blast of the new Cathy.

There are a couple of things that really stood out to me in this pilot, first of all the inciting incident of the diagnoses happens before we join Cathy on her journey. This is economic storytelling and makes sense, in a cop show you don’t reveal the main character is a cop halfway through and in a show about a woman with cancer you might as well start with that too. We are not presented with her life pre-cancer and whether she was enjoying it or tolerating it. Second she doesn’t tell anyone that she has cancer, so to all the other characters it could seem like she is having some kind of mid-life crisis. Having lived her life for the benefit of others the change that comes with cancer sees her behaviour change, but focus remain the same.  She still wants the best for those in her life, but rather than supporting them as she has always done, she now slowly prepares them for a life without her.

For the most part the pilot is a series of set ups and reveals which make the unfolding story easy to watch and satisfying when we witness each pay off.  The characters are likeable and despite the subject matter the show is upbeat and life affirming rather than sad and depressing. Each series is suppose to span over one season, so this first series is set in the summer, the second series Autumn etc. Sounds fine for the adults, but the son is going to dramatically age over the next year of his TV life.  The creator has also promised not shy from reality and like we all knew the fate of the Titanic we also know what lies in wait for Cathy.

Final thoughts on this show are little ho-hum, I liked it, it was charming, but it did little to push the envelope of drama on TV and I am not sure how many life affirming storylines I can take before I get bored and the promised guest stars Idris Elba, Brian Cox, Liam Neeson and Cynthia Nixon are unlikely to pull me back.

Created / Written by: Darlene Hunt
Directed by: Bill Condon
Starring: Laura Linney, Oliver Platt, Gabriel Basso, John Benjamin Hickey, Phyllis Somerville
Date premièred: 16th August 2010
UK Details: TBC

Review: Identity

Monday, July 12th, 2010

British drama has a bad rap round here, it has been a long time since a British show grabbed my attention, however in fairness it has not been since the second episode of Breaking Bad that I have really felt hooked on a new show. ITV’s latest offering is Identity, a drama that follows the investigators involved in identity fraud.

The series opens with a bang, a policeman lying in the street having been shot during a tense stand off in a suburban street. The man responsible for the shooting claims he is the victim of identity fraud and that someone else has committed the crimes he is accused of, of course that doesn’t explain why he shot a policeman. Anyway when the siege has ended the Identity Fraud squad enter and start to chase down leads to find the man responsible. Paper trials and witness interviews all climax in an action chase scene around a school.

The problem with bad cop shows is that the protagonist can be a bit of a mystery, this is a classic example of not knowing who we are suppose to care about. Do we care about the man who had his identity stolen, but then shot a cop? Do we care about the investigators who are just doing their job? Do we care about the identity thief who had his own life taken from him? Me personally I didn’t care about any of them, no one really had to make a tough choice and there was no stake raising towards the end, nothing to lose and nothing to gain. Even though the camera kept whizzing around, at the end of the day it was all about following receipts and making connections that is all pretty dull when that is being spoon fed to you and crazy action chases mean nothing if you are not emotionally involved. In the end we learn that one of the Fraud Squad is leading a double life in a Turkish criminal gang, so we can presume that this will provide the series arc, but why just throw it in in the last three minutes of the show? It comes from nowhere and feels like an after thought.

Identity fraud can screw up your life, there is no doubt about that, but trying to capture that from the point of view of the investigators is just dull, no matter how many chases you throw in. With another five episodes to go it is unclear what more they can throw at the screen to fool me into thinking that identity fraud is a ticking time bomb of destruction. Watch the trailer below to see just how overblown this is…

Created / Written by: Ed Whitmore
Directed by: Brendan Maher
Starring: Aidan Gillen, Keeley Hawes, Holly Aird, Elyes Gabel, Shaun, Patrick Baladi
Date premièred: 5 July 2010 – ITV1

Double Review: Memphis Beat and Justified

Wednesday, June 30th, 2010

It seems like drama has moved south. A trend perhaps started by True Blood and followed by Treme, The Good Guys, Outlaw Country, the recently wrapped up Justified and new entry Memphis Beat. Since these last two have more than little in common I will review both now.

Justified starts with U.S Marshal Raylan Givens (Timothy Olyphant) sat down with a known fugitive, he offers him the choice to leave town or die, pulling a gun on Raylan seals his fate, but that is one too many shootings and Raylan is reassigned to is home town in Kentucky. Here childhood friend Boyd Crowder(Walton Goggins has turned into redneck racist and is not only responsible for the murder of one of his gang members but also for launching a rocket into a black church. Tracking down Crowder leads Raylan to cross paths with his past, an ex-wife, a childhood admirer and the mystery of surround his estranged father. Ultimately it all leads to showdown where he is placed in a similar situation as the first scene and has to make the call about shooting his childhood friend.

Based on the character created by Elmore Leonard the pilot sets up that all too familiar police dynamic and while Raylan maybe more gentleman than brute force, his unconventional methods still rials up his boss. With The Shield finishing on such a high last year, it was great to see the return of the brilliant Walton Goggins to the TV screens, he manages to infuse real character in what could a horrible stereotype in other hands. The pilot serves to set up the interesting characters and dynamics, but as a result feels a little back story heavy with many key events taking place prior to the first episode. With a setting that takes us out of the cities we have become use to in other cop shows, there is certainly scope for fresh storylines. However, although bold in the early stages highlighting the consequence of a policeman shooting his gun, by the end you get the feeling that as long as it is a bad guy getting shot, that is all the justification needed.

In the pilot episode of Memphis Beat we are introduced to Dwight Hendricks (Jason Lee) a policeman with very good instincts. When an abused old woman is brought into the station, Dwight learns she was once a great radio DJ who first introduced him to Elvis (he is now an Elvis impersonator in  his spare time).  Emotionally involved in the case his new boss does not approve of his unconventional methods, constantly taking him off the case, this however does not stop his investigation until he finds her abuser.

From the first shot of Jason Lee you start to wonder if this is suppose to be a comedy, then you see the scrawny DJ Qualls in uniform and you know think it is a comedy, then when the first criminal’s trousers fall down, you sigh as it becomes “that type of comedy”. But that is where the comedy ends and a run of the mill police drama starts. Characters are flat and one note facing few, if any consequences for their actions. Only two things stand out, the music (an excellent from soundtrack from start to finish) and the setting. Dwight’s amazing instincts are often mentioned, but there is no explanation about where this comes from, he is no Mentalist and his skills serve only to move the plot forward in a quick and convenient way.

So in a quick summary, Memphis Beat sees Southern gentleman cop Dwight Hendricks solve crime with his unique powers of insight which goes against his by the book boss’ wishes. Justified meanwhile takes place in neighbouring state where U.S Marshal and southern gentleman Raylan Givens upsets his by the book boss because of a trigger happy finger.

Memphis Beat did nothing to peak my interest, I did not get involved with the main character and the horrible mix of comedy and drama was off balance and distracting. I have made it through the first series of Justified and much like the pilot there are some stand out moments that raise it above the usual network offerings, but it is not bold or fresh enough to stand up against other police dramas such as The Shield and The Wire. Law enforcement will always be a popular choice for drama, like medical shows it allows for an easy, self contained story each week, but it is such a well trodden path that you have to throw in something new to win me over.

I’m already dreading the next police drama on my review list Rookie Blue.

Memphis Beat
Created / Written by: Josh Harto and Liz Garcia
Directed by: John Fortenberry
Starring: Jason Lee, Alfre Woodard, DJ Qualls, Celia Weston, Sam Hennings, Leonard Earl Howze, Abraham Benrubi
Date premièred: 22nd June 2010 (TNT)
UK Details: TBC

Justified
Created / Written by: Graham Yost based the character created Elmore Leonard and his short story “Fire in the Hole”
Directed by: TBC
Starring: Timothy Olyphant, Nick Searcy, Erica Tazel, Jacob Pitts, Joelle Carter, Natalie Zea,
Date premièred: 16th March 2010 (FX)
UK Details: 5th May 2010 (FIVE USA)

Review: Persons Unknown

Wednesday, June 23rd, 2010

The season finale of Lost has left a hole that many want to fill.  They think the trick is to hook an audience in with a big mystery with the promise that if they just keep watching all the answers will be revealed. Persons Unknown comes from the fine writing pedigree that brought us The Usual Suspects and said to be carefully constructed over a 13 episode arch.  Interestingly this series has been financed differently to the norm, FOX pre-sold the series to international markets, then made it in locations that offer great tax breaks, the finished series was then shopped to US networks where NBC picked it up.

The story opens when single mother Janet is in the park with her daughter, distracted by issues relating to her ex-husband her daughter goes missing.  Panicked Janet looks for her before being kidnapped herself.  She wakes up in a hotel, quickly she finds she is not the only one kidnapped.  There is a stereotypical soldier, stereotypical party girl, the man who doesn’t want t talk about his past, the man who owns a car dealership, a woman with medical knowledge. Together they start exploring outside the hotel where they find themselves in a ghost town.  Two of them decide to leave, but when reaching the end of the road they pass out.  Panicked the remaining members hide until Chinese restaurant opens up, failing to get answers from the staff about why they have kidnapped they settle down to dinner. At the end of the meal they open fortune cookies which I assume will mean more later on in the series.  After a tough day with no questions answered the group return to the hotel, because what else is there to do.

When I first heard about this series I thought it was going to be like the excellent low budget movie Cube , an interesting study on character and how the individual’s unique skills benefit the group. This is not however where Persons Unknown is heading.

I think a lot of people still feel burnt by Lost, the set up of a big mystery and then the failure to deliver on that promise.  Flash Forward which in many ways was gearing up to take over the sprawling interwoven sci-fi hole left by Lost was cancelled after the first series leaving people with a bizarre cliff-hanger and no answers. Persons Unknown may fall foul to audience apathy as the pilot fails to explain anything, instead just opening more mystery.  The characters never really make any bold choice or learn from their experience, they all follow each other around like a pack of sheep as if individualism and character might get in the way of devices that lead the plot. When Lost first started individual character journey’s was what grabbed the audience the mystery came second.  In Persons Unknown the mystery is right up front and is the only thing people talk about, I don’t care about these characters because the writers have given me nothing.  Sure she has a child who will now be raised by a possibly abusive grandmother, but I have not seen anything of that child to care.  It is a cheat, shorthand tricks for why should feel and urgency for the characters to escape.

Three episodes in and the series is already haemorrhaging viewers at such rate that the full 13 episodes may not broadcast, another reason why viewers may not keep tuning in, they have been down this path before investing in a show only to see it get cancelled.

Created / Written by: Christopher McQuarrie
Directed by: Michael Rymer
Starring: Alan Ruck,  Jason Wiles,  Daisy Betts, Chadwick Boseman, Kate Lang Johnson, Gerald Kyd, Tina Holmes, Sean O’Bryan, Lola Glaudini
Date premièred: 7th June 2010 (NBC)
UK Details: TBA


Pilot Watch is proudly powered by WordPress, Install WordPress. web hosting
Entries (RSS) and Comments (RSS).

Privacy Policy