Would be better with a whiff of originality.
To say that I have been underwhelmed by 2010′s fall offerings is a huge understatement and even before watching the pilot to Better With You my heart was sinking at the prospect of writing yet another a generic review to another generic sit-com. ABC has placed this show between two of last year’s big hits The Middle and the Emmy award winning Modern Family
making it the only traditional multi-camera sitcom in the 2 hour line up of Wednesday night comedy (the fourth was show is another hit from last year Cougar Town).
The show opens by presenting us with three couples, the first have been together for 2 months and still want to make out at every opportunity, the second have been together for 9 years remained unmarried and yet finish each other sentences, the final couple have been together for 35 years and don’ talk at all. As the episode unfolds we learn that the two younger girls are sisters, the older couple their parents. Neither of the sisters are married, although the older one in a long term relationship claims it is a life choice, until her younger sister gets in engaged. The positive reaction by her parents to announcement of a wedding and a baby causes her to rethink this choice.
This show was exactly what I expected. Shana Goldberg-Meehan is a former writer on Friends and the 20 / 30 something angst is transferred over here only now it feels tired and overdone. While watching Better With You it can feel like watching a show from 90s, it is tame, predictable, bland and packed with characters we have seen a dozen times before. The weak jokes are based on characters being too stupid to exist, for example the older sister telling the boyfriend of her younger sister that she doesn’t want to get married until her social security becomes insolvent – this requires all three to be stupid – the boyfriend belives it, the girlfriend doesn’t question it and sister thinks this titbit will delay the engagement. I know this is a comedy and not a serious drama and perhaps I could let this go if the script wasn’t packed so many more clunkers. It is bad writing on the one episode that has to stand up stronger than all the others.
A sign of the troubles facing the show is the inability to get a title to stick, previous titles included Better Together, Leapfrog and That Couple – if you are so unsure of your story that you can’t nail a title, get out before you waste any more of your money. really want to know how shows like this get made, let alone get given a series. If anyone knows please leave a comment.
Created / Written by: Shana Goldberg-Meehan
Directed by: James Burrows
Starring: Joanna Garcia, Jennifer Finnigan, Josh Cooke, Jake Lacy, Kurt Fuller, Debra Jo Rupp
Date premièred: 22nd September 2010
UK Details: TBA










