Posts Tagged ‘medical’

Review: Pulse

Monday, June 7th, 2010

BBC3 has opened its doors to give viewers a sneak peak into three new shows it has lined up.  This started with supernatural, medical horror Pulse which debuted online one week before its TV broadcast and followed up a week later with Stanley Park and Dappers, but more on those in the coming days, but today we start with Pulse.

A great starting point for any horror is to identify a common fear and then exploit it.  For many hospitals, although being a place of healing can also be terrifying, you don’t check in if there is nothing wrong with you and while you are there you have to put your faith in these doctors who supposedly have your best interest at heart, but are at the end of the day just doing their job.  So with the setting seemingly right how does this new BBC pilot play out?

Hannah resumes her training at one of the country’s top teaching hospitals, it has been a year since she broke down following the death of her mother.  Haunted by spectres in mirrors Hannah finds herself reluctantly following her in mother’s footsteps in career she is not sure she really wants to be in. Her dedication to one particular patient leads her to discover that at night strange things are going on the hospital. Hannah’s former lover and promising surgeon Nick has problems of his own, following an operation he manages to infect himself with something that he needs to keep under control with frequent injections. Hannah soon discovers that he is involved with something paranormal when she is attacked by a corpse, freaking effected by the sickness Nick  Hannah away for her own safety promising to reveal all, instead he takes his life leaving Hannah with old questions unanswered and new ones burning. Are the experiments that go in the hospital just about saving lives or is there something far more sinister.

The show is determined to pack in as many horror clichés as it can, from the rotting corpse  appearing in the mirror, girl chased down corridors, locked in a library with a stranger, no one believes her, the double twist ending, unexpected people spring out from around corners the list goes on. Horror is a rare genre for TV series, the only one I can name with a continuing storyline is the unsuccessful Harper’s Island.  It seems audience need to resolve device laden issues that come along with horror in a single episode rather than over the course of the series.  Going back to the idea of a hospital as a scary place, the shift here is that we see that fear from the point of view of the doctors; it is something we can not so readily associate with.  Hannah is warned not to get too close to the patients, in doing she is more affected when something goes wrong, but this is also what opens her eyes to the dark side of the hospital. Since Hannah is on the inside, she should start to figure things out quickly. There is a danger that Pulse could fall into the same traps as True Blood where twists are either so obvious the reveal, when it comes, is a major disappoint or so hidden that it feels like it was plucked at random.

Right now Pulse has failed to grab me, sure there is some crazy shit going on in the hospital, but if I am going to invest my time into something I need to care about the characters and their relationships.  The main character Hannah is such a loner in the first episode that she fails to have even one meaningful friendship. I assume that sooner or later the other interns will get dragged into what is going on behind the scenes of the hospital, but right now one believer and cast of sceptics or conspirators does little to perk my interest.

Created / Written by: Paul Cornell, Ben Teasdale and Tom McRae.
Directed by: James Hawes
Starring: Stephen Campbell Moore, Claire Foy, Ben Miles, Caroline Goodall, Arsher Ali, Emily Beecham, Alan Williams, Gregg Chillin, Matti Houghton, Eileen Davies
Date premièred: 3rd June 2010 – BBC3 (available on iplayer 27th June 2010)

Review: Mercy

Wednesday, October 7th, 2009

As I have said before, 2009 sees no less that 8 new medical dramas each looking to find its niche. Mercy decided to view the hospital from the point of view of the unsung heroes known as the nurses, this of course might have been an original idea had not Showtime already produced Nurse Jackie and TNT produced Hawthrone.  With the loss of ER this is an important show for NBC and although planned to air mid season it was rushed out to fill the gap caused by a delay in the production of Parenthood.

Don’t under estimate the nurses, on her way to work Veronica (Taylor Schilling) attends the victim of a car crash after the saving some guys life, she threatened with law suit after his fiancé discovers she is only a nurse and therefore knows nothing. In actual fact Veronica the sexy nurse is an Iraq vet who has seen it all, we don’t know how she ended up back in a New Jersey hospital, but I am sure there is a good reason. New girl Chloe (Michelle Trachtenberg) arrives for her first day and despite being top of her class the slightest whiff of reality freezes her in her tracks. There is the usual office politics and power games between the doctors as Veronica up stages them with her in depth knowledge.  Of course her private life doesn’t run smoothly either, separated from her husband she sneaks off for rendezvous with one of the Doctors and at the end of a busy day the girls all head down to the local bar.

Comparisons to Nurse Jackie are immediately obvious; our lead character is a nurse, with a wealth of experience that surpasses the doctors. She rebels against authority for the good of the patient and carries out an affair with one of the doctors. Fair enough, it is understandable why a show would pick such a professionally moral character, with slight amoral private life.  Then we turn to the other nurses, we have the new girl Chloe who has a love for colourful scrubs, we switch to nurse Jackie where we have the new girl Zoey… who has a love for colourful scrubs. Then we have the shaven headed ethnic gay nurse, sure, Mercy has the Hispanic Angel, while Nurse Jackie has the middle eastern Mo-mo. This is not to say that Mercy has stolen these ideas and characters, it is just one of those horrible coincidences that must have made series creator Liz Heldens’ head burst. On the plus side not everyone has Showtime, so for majority of the audience these characters will feel at least somewhat fresh and original.

In conclusion this is just another medical drama that fails to throw anything new into the mix.  Nurse Jackie felt more real even though the situations were more exaggerated.  When you look at 46 year Edie Falco you think there is someone who has seen it all, but young newcomer Taylor Schilling would more easily pass as an intern than an experienced nurse. The nurses work hard and they play hard, if you like medical drama, this will probably float your boat, if you want more out of hour of TV you probably aren’t watching this anyway.

Created and Written by: Liz Heldens
Directed by: Adam Bernstein
Starring: Taylor Schilling, Jaime Lee Kirchner, Michelle Trachtenberg, James Tupper, Diego Klattenhoff, James LeGros, Delroy Lindo, Kate Mulgrew, Guillermo Díaz
Date premièred: 23rd September 2009
UK Details: TBC


Pilot Watch is proudly powered by WordPress, Install WordPress. web hosting
Entries (RSS) and Comments (RSS).

Privacy Policy